You’re due for a checkup. You feel fine. So, should you get a PSA test?
This has been a problematic question in medicine. The philosophy of late has been that all men are eventually going to get prostate cancer, and doctors have come to the point of saying that you are either going to die with prostate cancer or from prostate cancer. It almost sounds trite. The challenge is figuring out which group you are in.
Things are now changing. If you’re 50 to 69 and at average risk for prostate cancer, the American Cancer Society, as of November 2026, recommends a PSA blood test every two years. If you’re Black or have a close relative who had prostate cancer, the recommendation is to start at 45. How often you get tested depends on your risk.
The tricky part is what happens if the result comes back high. Could it be a laboratory error? Yes, that is possible, and repeating the test is worthwhile. But if it still comes back high, then you and your physician need to have a serious discussion. More on that in a bit, but first, a bit on the prostate, then who and when to test:
The Prostate
This gland in men is located just under the bladder and near the rectum, and the urethra passes through it. In young men, it is about the size of a walnut but grows as we age. It produces some of the fluid that makes up semen.
When the prostate turns cancerous, it is almost always an adenocarcinoma. Rarely, there are small cell cancers also known as neuroendocrine carcinoma, or large cell carcinomas and also transitional cell carcinomas. Most prostate cancers grow very slowly. There are about 333,000 new cases per year with about 36,000 deaths per year. About 1 in 8 men will be diagnosed with prostate cancer during their lifetimes, but 6 in 10 prostate cancers are diagnosed in men older than 65 years. Prostate cancer risk is highest in those who are Black. Death from prostate cancer is second only to lung cancer in men. Family history of prostate cancer also is concerning. Another risk for prostate cancer is having the BRCA 1 or 2 gene. Other genes that raise the risk include CHEK2, ATM, PALB2, NBN, FANCA, and RAD51. Men with an inherited change in one of these genes have a condition called Lynch Syndrome, which also puts them at increased risk for colorectal cancer as well.
Prostate Cancer Screening: When to start and how often to test
Here’s the schedule the American Cancer Society recommends for men who feel well and are being screened for prostate cancer:
- Average risk. Get a PSA test every two years from age 50 through 69.
- Black men. Get tested every year from age 45 through 69. Black men are more likely to develop prostate cancer and die from it, which is why the society recommends starting earlier and testing more often.
- Men who have a father, brother, or son who had prostate cancer have a higher risk of prostate cancer.. Start at 45 and continue through 69. Get tested every year if one of those relatives was diagnosed before 65 or if two or more were diagnosed at any age. If only one was diagnosed and he was 65 or older, get tested every two years.
If you know you carry an inherited gene change such as BRCA2, or a close relative has one, bring that up with your doctor. It can affect when you start screening and how often you’re tested.
What if you’re 70 or older?
From age 70 through 74, the decision depends more on your overall health, your previous results, and how you feel about going through further testing if your PSA is high. If you and your doctor decide to continue, the society recommends testing every two years.
Routine screening generally ends at 75. A man in very good health between 75 and 79 may still want to discuss it, especially if his PSA has been rising. The society recommends against screening at age 80 and older, or at any age when someone is unlikely to live another 10 years. Screening benefit takes time to show up, while the downsides of a biopsy or treatment may manifest much sooner.
What does a PSA test actually tell you?
PSA is “prostate-specific antigen,” a protein made by the prostate. A blood test measures how much is circulating in your blood. Prostate cancer can raise PSA, and so can common problems such as an enlarged prostate or inflammation. A low PSA makes cancer less likely, though some men with prostate cancer still have a low result. PSA itself may rise naturally with age as the prostate enlarges with age, a condition known as BPH or benign prostatic hypertrophy. Typical acceptable safe PSA levels due to enlarging prostates with increasing age are ages 40-49 generally less than 2.5; 50 to 59 generally under 3.5; 60 to 69 generally under 4.5; and 70 to 79 generally up to 6.5.
So why recommend regular testing? The American Cancer Society now has stronger evidence that screening can reduce the chances of being diagnosed with advanced prostate cancer or dying from it. Doctors also have better ways to follow up an elevated result and decide who needs a biopsy. That matters because screening can find slow-growing cancers that would never cause trouble during a man’s lifetime. Finding one and overcalling it can mean more tests, more worry, and sometimes treatment that offers little benefit.
What happens if your PSA comes back high?
This is often the part that worries people most. The usual next step is to repeat the blood test in two weeks to three months. A single result can be high for a transient reason.
If the repeat test is still high, your doctor may recommend a prostate MRI, a specialized blood or urine test, or both. The MRI can show areas of the prostate that look suspicious. Other tests help estimate the chance of finding a cancer that needs attention. Together with your PSA and medical history, these results help your doctor decide whether to recommend a biopsy. A very high PSA or other concerning findings can lead to an earlier biopsy recommendation.
What if a biopsy does find cancer?
Some prostate cancers grow slowly enough that it’s reasonable to watch them closely. If a biopsy finds a cancer with a low risk of growing or spreading, the American Cancer Society recommends offering active surveillance first.
That means keeping up with scheduled PSA tests, repeat biopsies, and sometimes MRIs. If those checks show the cancer is becoming more likely to grow or spread, you and your doctor can revisit treatment. For some men, that approach can delay or avoid side effects from treatment, including problems with bladder control, erections, or bowel function. Before choosing surveillance, make sure you know what follow-up involves and when your next visit is due.
Alan Spira, MD, DTM&H, November 2026
Take the Next Step: Talk to Your Doctor About PSA Testing
Deciding when to start PSA screening isn’t always straightforward. Your age, family history, personal risk factors, and overall health all play a role in determining whether testing is right for you and how often it should be repeated.
At The Village Doctor, we believe preventive care starts with understanding your individual health risks and making informed decisions alongside a physician who knows your medical history. If you’re approaching screening age, have a family history of prostate cancer, or simply want to discuss whether a PSA test makes sense for you, we’re here to help.


